&

Thursday, September 5, 2013

Should I Get My Stryker Rejuvenate Removed?



“Should I get my Stryker Rejuvenate removed?” This is the question on the minds of many of those who received a recalled Rejuvenate or ABGII and are now experiencing health issues as a result. It might seem an easy decision for those who have suffered total failure of the Stryker hip implant or who have suffered symptoms of metal toxicity yet it may not be that clear a choice. Revision surgery for the Stryker Rejuvenate or ABGII is both serious and complex. Removal of the hip implant devices includes removing the neck implant piece using a modular neck extractor which is placed under the base of the neck, and, in some cases may need the help of a mallet to completely extract the neck piece. The stem is removed next, using a modular stem extractor which implements a connection pin and locking arm. Stem extraction in these Stryker models is considered risky as the bone can shatter during the extraction.

Recovery Following Stryker Revision Surgery
Recovery time following revision surgery of a Rejuvenate or ABGII can be significantly longer than that of the original implant surgery. Such a long recovery time can impact every aspect of the patient’s life. If the patient is unable to return to work for up to six weeks, jobs could be lost and wages will certainly be forfeited. Medical expenses can mount alarmingly, and the inability to perform day-to-day tasks during recovery can lead to necessary assistance. Those patients who suffered a broken femur during the revision surgery may have to be in a wheelchair for months while the femur heels before revision surgery can be completed.

Why Should I Get My Stryker Rejuvenate Removed?
The reasoning behind having a Stryker Rejuvenate or ABGII removed generally centers around fretting and corrosion which in turn can lead to inflammation, chronic pain and tissue and bone degradation or loss. Once the bone and tissue surrounding the Stryker hip implant begin to deteriorate the Stryker implant may loosen. This loosening can lead to a total failure of the hip implant. Further, symptoms of metal toxicity including hearing and vision loss, disruption of DNA, depression, irritability and anxiety, vertigo, gastrointestinal, cardiovascular, renal and thyroid problems and the development of pseudo-tumors can trigger the decision to replace the all-metal Stryker implant with a ceramic or polyethylene hip device.

Making the Necessary Decisions to Have Your Stryker Rejuvenate Removed
If you and your doctor feel your Stryker hip implant must be removed in order to preserve your mobility and your health, you must collect a certain amount of information. You will need to know the name of the surgeon who performed your initial Stryker hip implant as he or she could be called to testify during a future lawsuit. Contacting the surgeon or the hospital where your initial surgery took place will give you the Stryker model you were implanted with. A second surgical opinion could be helpful during this time so you can be certain you should get your Stryker Rejuvenate removed. After you have made the necessary decisions as far as whether you will have your Stryker implant removed, it may be a positive step for your future to look into your legal options.

Is Dual Modularity the Real Defect of the Stryker Rejuvenate? How the Rejuvenate Recall May Affect Recipients of the Implant



This past July Stryker Orthopedics recalled two hip implant models: the Rejuvenate and the ABGII. The Rejuvenate gained FDA approval only a few short years earlier, in 2008. The approval for the Rejuvenate fell under a process known as the 510(k) which has come under fire after many devices approved under the process were found to be defective. Under this process a new medical device must only show it is substantially equivalent to a device which has already garnered FDA approval. Clinical trials are not a requirement of the 510(k), therefore many people have ended up harmed from a defective medical device approved under this process.

In fact, the Rejuvenate received FDA approval based on its similarity to the Wright Profemur modular neck device. The Pro-femur has not been recalled, however since its introduction to the market in 2000, there have been a significant number of adverse reports regarding the device as well as injury lawsuits filed against the company. Many of these lawsuits allege that Wright was aware of the problems associated with the Pro-femur including an unusually high risk of failure and fracture. Like the Rejuvenate, the Pro-femur also has a significant risk of fretting and corrosion.

Is the Stryker Rejuvenate Defective Because of the Dual Modularity?
Originally all hip implants were designed with one junction between the ball and the neck portion. Dual modularity implemented a junction between the ball and the neck as well as a junction between the neck and the stem. Stryker’s goal with the new dual modularity design was to allow surgeons to use multiple necks with various angles and lengths so a custom fit for each individual patient could be obtained.

The surgeon can choose the size and length of the ball, the length of the stem section, the shape and size of the upper end of the femoral component and the degree of rotation and offset. While in theory the dual modularity hip implant device should provide a huge gain in performance as well as putting an end to safety issues which occurred from a poor fit. But dual modularity design also increases the likelihood of separation between the body and the neck, thus increasing the levels of metal ion debris.

When Dual Modularity Causes Corrosion
There are three types of corrosion the Rejuvenate is subject to: crevice corrosion, fretting corrosion and galvanic corrosion. When a dual modularity device such as the Stryker Rejuvenate is used, a good taper must be implemented at the modularity points. Many hip implant manufacturers use a Morse taper however due to a variety of manufacturers, the tapers are not uniform in their dimensions. Even the slightest variance can greatly increase the risk of dislocation for the patient.

The Morse taper may also connect two disparate materials which can also increase the risks of fretting and corrosion. When a ceramic femoral head is used, the Morse tapers which join the head with the shaft can produce stress within the ceramic material. These are known as hoop stresses and can lead to serious fractures of the ceramic head when products of two different manufacturers are placed together.  As you can see, the dual modularity of the Stryker Rejuvenate could well be reason for the recall.

Tuesday, September 3, 2013

How are the Stryker ABGII and the Rejuvenate Different?



The Stryker Rejuvenate hip implant device received FDA approval in June of 2008, while the ABGII hip implant device received FDA approval in November, 2009. Just a few short years later the FDA began receiving adverse reports regarding both hip implants. In April, 2012 Stryker issued an Urgent Field Safety Notice to doctors and hospitals stating the risks of fretting and corrosion, leading to metal ion debris. These microscopic cobalt and chromium ions can enter the bloodstream or lodge in nearby hip tissues, creating a host of adverse health issues.

When the shards burrow into the hip tissues, inflammation, chronic pain and the destruction and death of tissue and bone can occur. Should the cobalt and chromium enter the bloodstream, metal toxicity can occur, resulting in cardiovascular, neurological, renal, thyroid and gastrointestinal issues, loss of vision and hearing, the development of pseudo-tumors, DNA disruption, chromosomal abnormalities, chronic headaches, vertigo, depression, anxiety, and irritability.

Following the field safety notification, Stryker issued a recall of both the ABGII and the Rejuvenate in July, 2012. Between the time the devices received FDA approval and the time of the recall, over 20,000 implants were sold; it is believed most of those were implanted into patients. While Stryker claims their failure rate to be somewhere around 12%, independent studies have placed the risk of failure much higher—some as high as 48-50%. This means that while the lawsuits presently number in the low hundreds, it is likely there will be many more filed in the next year.

The Similarities Between the Rejuvenate and the ABGII
The basic design of the ABGI and Rejuvenate vary considerably from the design of other metal-on-metal hip implant devices. The primary differences revolve around the fact that the Rejuvenate and the ABGII implement a ceramic ball rather than a cobalt and chromium ball as many other all-metal devices. In fact, it was widely believed that Stryker’s Rejuvenate and ABGII would not cause the same adverse health risks of the other metal implants due to the ceramic component included in the design.

The design of these two Stryker devices kept a metal neck and stem piece, and offered a wide variety of sizes and lengths of components in order to allow the surgeon to piece together a hip implant which would most closely align with the individual’s body type and level of activity. Unfortunately, the claims of Stryker regarding the Rejuvenate and ABGII did not pan out as expected. The metal joints between metal parts bring a significant risk of fretting and corrosion due to the movement in the joints.  

Differences in the Stryker ABGII and the Rejuvenate
Perhaps the primary difference between the two recalled Stryker hip implants is the hydroxyapatite porous coating; while the coating of the Rejuvenate is very rough and deep, encouraging the bone to grow deeply into the coating, the coating of the ABGII is much shallower and smoother. During revision surgery, the coating of the ABGII makes it considerably easier to remove the device and implant another. Both the ABGII and the Rejuvenate stems are manufactured using a propriety blend of titanium, molybdenum, zirconium and iron. While Stryker claimed this innovative mixture would resist fretting and corrosion, post-market data did not support that claim.

The neck piece of both devices is constructed from cobalt and chromium, however the proportions of the metals are somewhat different. The stem of the Rejuvenate is longer than the stem of the ABGII, again, making the Rejuvenate more difficult to remove during revision surgery as it is implanted more deeply into the femur. If you are the recipient of either a Stryker ABGII or Rejuvenate it is important that you speak with your physician regarding your levels of cobalt and chromium.

Wednesday, June 19, 2013

What Patients Must Know About the Titanium Hip Replacement Recall: When Stryker Rejuvenate Patients Suffer Effects from Titanium



The Stryker Rejuvenate and ABGII were both recalled this past July after it was found the implants had a higher-than-normal risk of causing fretting, corrosion and the potential for metal ion debris to enter the body. Up until now, the focus regarding those metal ions has been on the cobalt and chromium shards which can lead to a variety of serious health issues including metal toxicity. The neck of the Rejuvenate and ABGII is constructed of the harder cobalt and chromium while the stem is constructed of titanium.

Titanium has generally been considered a “safe” metal therefore little attention has been given to the possible side effects of titanium. Titanium, over time, binds completely to bone and living tissue, minimizing the need for adhesives. The titanium component of the hip replacement device is also more flexible and lightweight than the cobalt and chromium component. Despite these “pluses” there may be risks inherent in a titanium hip implant component which few recipients are aware of.

Titanium Allergies Could Cause Problems in Rejuvenate Recipients
Metal allergies have been researched as they relate to metal hip implants because some thirty percent of the population have a metal sensitivity to nickel, and the cobalt and chromium implant contains at least 1% nickel. Titanium allergies, on the other hand, are a barely recognized problem. It is a fairly recent occurrence that a test known as MELISA® can test for titanium sensitivity although the test cannot measure serum levels of titanium in the bloodstream as tests for cobalt and chromium can do. Labs using the MELISA® test report that 4% of all patients tested for titanium sensitivity test positive.

Titanium Allergies Cause a Variety of Health Problems
Titanium sensitivity can be very frustrating for those who have the allergy as their symptoms can be somewhat vague and may be wrongly attributed to other health issues. Skin rashes in the hip implant area, muscle pain and fatigue, Chronic Fatigue Syndrome and chronic thigh pain may all indicate an allergy to titanium. Titanium is not only used in metal hip implants such as the Stryker Rejuvenate and ABGII, it can be found in many everyday articles including certain food coatings, cosmetics, sunscreen, medicine coatings, paint, certain whitening toothpastes, jewelry, vitamin supplements and even the hard candy coating found on Skittles and M & M’s.

Stryker Rejuvenate Patients May Be Subject to Titanium Corrosion
Like most all metals, corrosion causes a release of metal ions which bind with body proteins. A person with an allergy to titanium may find their body will attempt to attack the foreign particles of titanium when sensitivities to the metal are present. This attack will cause inflammation in the hip area and likely pain to the victim. The MELISA® test is currently the only test which has been proven to diagnose titanium sensitivities. Additionally, several studies have concluded that titanium metals frequently contain small amounts of nickel as a result of the processing. Therefore a person who is sensitive to both titanium and nickel could have extremely strong reactions to a Stryker Rejuvenate or ABGII hip implant.

Studies on Titanium Allergies
A study done in 2006 tested fifty-six recipients of a titanium-based hip implant device after each patient experienced a variety of adverse health issues following the implantation. Testing was done on each patient to determine whether they had sensitivities to any of the ten metals including titanium. Of the 56, 21 tested positive for a titanium allergy, 16 patients tested “ambiguous,” and the remainder tested negative for a titanium allergy. Of the 56, all but two underwent revision surgery to replace their titanium-based hip implant with a different implant material and all 54 showed “remarkable” improvement of their adverse symptoms. The conclusion of the article was that titanium, in those who are sensitive to the metal, can cause “clinically relevant hypersensitivity in a subgroup of patients exposed to titanium implants.” 

A 2004 study detailed in the Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery followed nine patients with titanium-based hip replacements who all suffered from severe thigh pain which worsened at night despite a well-fixed implant and no sign of infection. Eight of the nine underwent revision surgery after x-rays showed deterioration of the femur at the tip of the titanium stem. Following revision, the tip of the removed titanium stem was found to be highly acidic with considerable evidence of corrosion. As to whether the cobalt and chromium ions react negatively with the titanium ions, this same article did note that galavanic corrosion is more likely to occur in a hip implant using dissimilar metals.

Two specific case studies done in England determined titanium allergies were the culprit for the adverse health issues and one of the patients also suffered from a nickel allergy as well. Fatigue, exhaustion, fevers, headaches, suppressed appetite, pain, swelling, neurological disturbances and even confusion were noted by the two patients, yet once their titanium-based implant was removed, the symptoms disappeared completely.

Patients with Suspected Titanium Allergies and a Rejuvenate Implant
Those who have suffered pain, fatigue, and other adverse symptoms following their Rejuvenate hip implant should request that a MELISA test be performed to determine whether they have an allergy to titanium. While science has not yet determined whether the cobalt and chromium ions can react negatively to the titanium ions, it is definitely a possibility. Despite the titanium hip replacement recall of the Rejuvenate and ABGII in July, 2012, many of those implanted with the devices continue to experience serious health issues.   

Wednesday, June 12, 2013

What Patients Should Know Regarding the Stryker Rejuvenate Hip Recall: Theories of Design Defects Which Led to the Stryker Hip Recall



As more and more recipients of metal-on-metal hip implants experience serious adverse symptoms from the devices there will be more information on the design defects in these devices which have caused the problems. Stryker Orthopedics recalled their Rejuvenate and ABGII in 2012, only a few short years after the implants received FDA approval and began being marketed. Like the recalled DePuy ASR, as time passes more and more defects are being found in the design of the hip implants. When Stryker recalled the Rejuvenate and ABGII they stated the potential of fretting and corrosion at the neck juncture. Later it was found that corrosion could occur under the small metal trunnions located at both ends of the neck portion as body fluids became trapped underneath.

More recently it has come to light that there may be a serious mismatch between the titanium stem portion—which is coated with a proprietary mix of titanium, molybdenum, zirconium and iron mixed with plasma spray—and the cobalt and chromium neck. Studies as far back as 2002 found that corrosion is significantly higher in hip implants with mixed alloy parts versus parts which were all made of the same metal. In fact, mixed alloy hip implants were responsible for moderate to severe corrosion in 42% of hip implants as compared to 28% in implants constructed of only one metal. A study done as recently as 2012 concluded that when a titanium stem and cobalt and chromium adapter sleeve were mixed, a galvanic reaction which produced corrosion was much more likely. While it is theorized that the problem may occur because the cobalt and chromium components are much harder, scientists have not yet found a definitive reason for this phenomenon.

Why Frictional Torque May Be a Problem in the Stryker Rejuvenate and ABGII
Frictional torque could also be an issue in Stryker’s recalled hip implant devices. Stryker’s design was considered highly innovative as it implemented a variety of parts which allowed the surgeon to choose the best sizes for the individual patient. The modular neck of the Rejuvenate fits into the stem which leads to frictional torque where the two parts meet. This torque leads to significantly more wear on the joint and, in fact, a wear analysis concluded the majority of the wear occurred at the stem and neck juncture. As the bearing diameter increases, there is also an increase in mechanical stress which has been found to cause excessive cobalt ion release. This excessive wear is also responsible for pseudo-tumor formation. Retrieved head-neck tapers from a 1992 study showed that over one-third of the head-neck tapers showed moderate to severe corrosion due to the frictional torque at the juncture.

Cobalt Toxicity Due to TMZF Coating Issues
The TMCF coating used to coat the Stryker components was meant to circumvent the issue of mixing alloys as well as offer resistance to corrosion and fretting, however data disproves that theory. Fretting and corrosion do still occur, sending microscopic metal ions into the tissue surrounding the implant and into the bloodstream. When the ions have built up in the body, metal toxicity can occur leading to such symptoms as deterioration of vision and hearing, DNA disruption, the formation of pseudo-tumors, pain, cardiovascular, renal, thyroid and neurological disorders, depression, anxiety, irritability, vertigo, skin disorders and gastrointestinal issues. The ions which are shearing away from the neck/stem juncture appear to be comprised of more cobalt than chromium. This is somewhat puzzling as in other metal-on-metal hip implants measured levels of cobalt and chromium and generally much the same, while in patients of the Stryker Rejuvenate and ABGII the cobalt levels outpace the chromium levels. It is expected that Stryker Rejuvenate hip recall lawsuits will continue to mount as those who were implanted with the recalled devices will continue to experience adverse symptoms.